Tracking the products, trends and reach of China's local to global tech culture.
DEFINITION: Shanzai [San-zai -alt. sp.Shanzhai] 1. mountain fortress/bandit 2. a vendor, who operates a business without observing the traditional rules or practices often resulting in innovative and unusual products or business models.

COOLe clones HTC Snap, the legitimate Blackberry clone
Gadget Types - Phones
Written by Song Jiang   
Friday, 13 November 2009 16:24

Add story to:

Digg    Facebook    StumbleUpon    Newsvine    Deli.cio.us    reddit   
htcsnapclone1
Combining a cute wee trackball and a full qwerty keyboard, the less than memorably named COOLe8900-2 is a shanzhai ji phone very much inspired by HTC's Snap, which is in itself does a pretty good imitation of Blackberry's Curve. Let's take a moment to explore the relative merits of the shanzhai version compared to its HTC brethren and discuss the finer points of design inspiration.

In terms of stats the COOLe8900-2, (which from here on in I will refer to as the COOLe) is, like many thousands of phone designs in China, based on Mediatek's turnkey platform, while the HTC Snap is powered by a Qualcomm chip. In terms of screen size the COOLe gives you 2.2 inches with a 240 × 320 resolution, while the HTC is slightly larger at 2.4 inches at the same resolution.

If we look at the dimensions involved, the COOLe is 109mm × 58mm × 13.5mm while the HTC is slightly longer and wider but a shade thinner at 116.5mm x 61.5mm x 12.0 mm. One point five millimeters of thinness might seem negligible but on devices that sit in your pocket, it's still significant. As is weight. The shanzhai clone is 125 grams, which is 5 grams heavier than the HTC. Would I notice a five gram difference on a phone? Possibly.

htcsnapclone2
htcsnapclone3

Other major differences are mostly related to the platforms inside and the software that drives them. The Mediatek platform is feature-rich enough to do most video and music formats,  has a built in FM receiver and supports dual SIM cards. The COOLe is GSM ready and of course supports bluetooth. With the HTC, it really depends which version you get hold of. Sprint and Verison offer different versions with different configurations.

Which brings me to one thing I noticed. CNet reviewed the Sprint version of the HTC Snap and noted that they had modified the the navigation on the device replacing the track ball multi-directional keypad. Well Bonnie Cha, I got good news; the COOLe uses the ball, not the keypad.

htcsnapclone4
htcsnapclone6

Analysis:

We've noticed a couple of Blackberry clones appearing in the last few months and in fact it is possible that this wasn't intentionally imitating HTC at all, it could be a simple Blackberry clone that just happens to look like HTC's Snap. But this is all academic and of course due to the fact that HTC Snap actually is a device that is very, very similar to a Blackberry. For me this raises a few issues.

Firstly, in the CNet review that I mentioned above, Bonnie does not once use the word Blackberry, RIM, Research in Motion or indeed allude to the fact the HTC Snap looks almost exactly like a Blackberry. I find this incredibly odd, because if Jimmy Chen of Shenzhen makes his own version of a popular design, the Western media are usually compelled to scream blue murder from the rooftops, raising issues of IP protection and those dastardly Asians and their rip offs .. yada yada.

HTC are of course a well established Taiwan-owned company, but arguably because they have established themselves as an accepted brand name and spend few million dollars of their marketing budget to create an image of themselves which makes them acceptable to Western sensibilities. Therefore, the Snap just happens to look like a Blackberry. No crime here. Move along.

Conclusions:

The COOLe retails for approx USD85 and comes in black. Sounds like a good deal from where I'm standing, regardless of who or what influenced its conception, or what other devices it looks like.

[Article Source]

Banner




 

Comments  

 
0 # Tai-Pan 2009-11-13 17:03
"Jimmy Chen of Shenzhen" is that the Asian equivalent of John and Jane Doe??? I love it!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Babiken 2009-11-29 15:34
On Babiken website, I found this K688 and it claims it is a HTC copy. I just if it is.
www.babikenshop.com/.../
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Matthew 2010-01-20 00:57
Hi i have just recieved a phone that looks like the COOLe8900-2 HTC Snap clone it has duel sim, tv etc .I can not get the gprs working in the Uk.I have being intouch with Orange uk who say they can not help because this phone is not on there computer.I can not get the duel sim part working it does not recognise any sim cards in the second sim card slot. Can you help.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Jeco 2010-02-15 14:45
Ask the guys from chinamanuals.com - they gave me the Kuwaitian GPRS settings for my Blackberry clone. They even have the COOLe8900-2user manual available!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

English Chinese (Simplified) Chinese (Traditional) French German Italian Portuguese Russian Spanish
youtube friendfeedtwitter feedfacebook
Social Production & Operation Tablet Bag Design from:shanzai Studios

Buy Shanzhai

Banner
Banner

Idea Stream from Shanzai Studios

Below are the featured entries from Shanzai Studios iPad bag design project called "Operation Tablet Bag Design". Participating in Operation TBD is simple, free and gives you the chance to share ideas about a unique new product that will be tailored and manufactured to your needs.
  • Ultra-light Grippa
    Ultra-light Grippa
    A super light weight shoulder bag. Nothing much to it apart from light pieces of rubber and a hinge. The basic rubber frame holds the iPad...
  • Turtle Power! Bag
    Turtle Power! Bag
    This bag reminds me of the popular comic called: "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" I wouldn't mind wearing this bag the whole day to let people take...

Asia Analysis

chinamap
indiamap

Recent Shanzai Tweets

More Shanzhai Devices

Shanzhai Nokia concept phone
Frankenphone COOL E93 tryin' hard to look like Gary Cooper (super duper) Here’s an interesting piece of Shanzhai design. Touted as a “concept” machine, the COOL E93 (or is that N93? Take a look at the following...
More pics & analysis...
Eros Tablet PC – great for watching things of beauty…
Eros-tablet3In Greek mythology Eros was the god of love and beauty – more specifically, erotic love. I don’t know if the shanzhai manufacturers had this in mind when they came up with the name for this 10-inch to...
More pics & analysis...
Open source game console – build your own games
gp2x-wiz-1Based on Linux, the GP2X Wiz (nice name!) is a completely open multi-functional handheld entertainment device. The makers, GamePark Holding from Korea, say it’s different than other shanzhai video gam...
More pics & analysis...
Fujitsu Netbook hits Hong Kong for an incredible $700
fujitsu-m380-1Fujitsu's latest netbook offering was released in Hong Kong yesterday, causing wide spread head shaking and cries of incredulity with it's 690 USD price tag. Known as the Lifebook MH380, this Pinetrai...
More pics & analysis...
Google Nexus One vs Motorola DROID
Nexus_one_vs_DROID_01iPhones are still awesome but they’re also now just common possessions. So what’s the next best selling smartphone, the iPhone killer? With the launch of several Android powered smartphones, the featu...
More pics & analysis...

In Partnership with:

shanzhaibenlogo